The “shrubbery” effect
What is Nature?
Green and golden canopies of oak or beech, dense shrubs and ferns undergrowth, seasonal wildflowers, with rustling leaves and birdsong in cool, humid air. A temperate forest. Nature.
Endless yellow dunes baking under a blazing sun, dry heat radiating off sparse shrubs, occasional tough flowers struggling through the sand, with whispering winds, shifting sand, and distant suffocated bird calls. A sandy desert. Also nature.
Lush green shrubs and vibrant orange trees stretch under warm sunlight, their fragrant blossoms and ripe fruit filling the air, while a gentle breeze rustles leaves and carries the soft hum of bees and finchsong. An orchard. Not nature.
We have often encountered a misconception of Nature. Nature is neither pleasant nor unpleasant in itself. It exists independently of us, human beings. “Shrubberies”, orchards, and gardens, on the other hand, exist because of us: they are built by us to fulfill our purposes, whether being for production or for pleasure or both.
Defining Nature
Let us get into definitions, for a moment. There are several definitions of Nature, more or less complex but a standard, authoritative one comes from the Oxford English Dictionary:
“Nature (noun): The phenomena of the physical world collectively, including plants, animals, the landscape, and other features and products of the earth, as opposed to humans or human creations.”
The Hidden Complexity of Natural Systems
Nature allows for intricate and complex relations between species that have evolved through time, in a coordinated effort to optimise the use of resources. These relationships are not accidental but they are the result of countless adjustments, failures, and successes layered over millennia.
Each organism occupies a niche, contributes to cycles of matter and energy, and responds to the presence of others not only efficiently but also creating resilience. While we often enjoy nature’s beauty, tranquility, and resources, nature is indifferent to human desires.
Animals are everywhere in nature, but not on display. You can see some animals directly, others leave traces like tracks, droppings, nests, or sounds; many exist in layers of life we don’t immediately notice, like underground, inside trunks or in water. Plants, like animals, are everywhere in nature, but their location depends on climate, soil, water, and light conditions.
The Illusion of Green: Human-Made Landscapes
“Shrubberies”, orchards, or gardens are often green deserts. Although they appear lush and alive, they often lack structural diversity, seasonal variation, and ecological depth. They are created in a very short time compared to the long evolution of natural ecosystems, and rely on constant human care to exist.
The soil is disturbed, the understory cleared, and natural cycles are broken, leaving little for insects, birds, or fungi to depend on. They often contain only a few species, chosen for yield, appearance, or control.
Wildflowers, throughout evolution, prioritize survival and reproduction, whereas cultivated flowers prioritize beauty and human preference. So yes, the beautiful bougainvilleas that one finds in the nice green areas of the Mediterranean, in nothing resemble their wild version from South America, that grows as a woody vine in the forest. They are beautiful, but they are not Nature.
Alentejo Nature
Nature in Alentejo is resilient, adapted to harsh summers, and often looks sparse to the eye, but it’s full of hidden life. Soils are often poor and sandy, which shapes the type of vegetation that grows naturally.
We live amongst granite rocks where, now and there, a stone oak manages to survive, and the landscape is scattered by drought-resistant plants like rockrose, lavender, rosemary, thyme, and wild irises. And there are also the numerous fungi, mosses and lichens, above surfaces and underground.
Animals called this habitat their own, as the wild boar, rabbits and hares, genet, and mongoose. Eagles, buzzards and vultures dominate the high skies, while hoopoes, partridges and numerous smaller birds inhabit the lower spaces. The soil surface is a favorite place for lizards, snakes, and frogs, while insects occupy all layers, from underground to the high skies above.
Living Within
Where we live, it can be challenging at times: summers scorch and dry the earth, winters bring heavy rains, flowers are modest and shy, birds sing softly, and animals move on their own rhythm, rarely revealing themselves. Yet in this place, we don’t feel like spectators; we feel part of a living whole, a part of the pulse of the land itself.
We can not appease the Knights who say “Ni”(*) as we cannot provide them with a nice shrubbery. But we can welcome those who seek to connect with nature without judgment or expectation, those who are willing to notice the subtle signs of life, the small flowers, the tracks of animals, the textures of bark and soil, the changing light, and the sounds of wind and birds.
(*) reference to Monty Python and the Holy Grail, where the “Knights who say Ni” are impossible to satisfy—they demand a shrubbery” and are never content.

