Why Does It Stop at the Campsite Gate?
We are off-grid and that means that many things we process ourselfs. Garbage is an exception. For us, it is possible to properly treat garbage. We compost what we can, but further we simply collect the rest and bring it to the municipal collection point, where it can be fully processed and recycled. And here is where this story starts…
Every day, guests walk past clearly marked recycling bins. Often we find them filled with mixed waste and misplaced items. That leaves us struggling with the stubborn, unanswered question:
– why do some people just not seem to care?
At Home, Most People Know How
Whether a country embraced household waste separation in the 1990s or only fully implemented it much later, recycling has now been part of daily life for decades. Most of our guests come from places where sorting paper, glass, and organics is just second nature, a habit built over time, not a new concept. The coloured bins are familiar. Still, we’ve put up plenty of friendly signs to remind everyone exactly what goes where, how, and why, hoping to bridge the gap between knowing and doing. The knowledge is there. This makes the contrast we observe at the campsite all the more striking: people who carefully separate their waste at home often seem to abandon the habit as soon as they arrive on holiday.
Does the Holiday Mindset Change Everything?
We are reaching the conclusion that for many people, the answer is yes. Holidays often act as a gateway out of the rigid structures of daily life. For a few days or weeks, schedules become less important, alarms are silenced, and routines that normally guide our days are set aside. We cook less carefully, stay up later, eat at unusual hours, and allow ourselves small “guilty pleasures” that we would not consider at home. That is, after all, part of the appeal of a holiday: the feeling of freedom from obligations. Yet somewhere along the way, some habits that should have become second nature seem to be left behind as well, including something as simple as waste separation. It seems to us that for many people there is an unspoken thought: “I’m on holiday. Don´t tell me what to do.”
However, even on holidays, we fasten a seatbelt before driving off, switch off a light when leaving a room, or leave a door closed behind us almost automatically. These are not decisions we consciously weigh each time; they are habits. Some actions have become so deeply ingrained in our daily lives that we no longer think about them. Waste separation should belong in the same category: an instinctive action carried out wherever we are, whether at home, at work, or on holiday.
The Old Excuse: “It All Gets Mixed Together Anyway”
Many of us still fall back into the old excuse as a convenient justification for inaction. Indeed during the early years of modern recycling programmes (1970s-1980s), some reports revealed cases where separately collected recyclables were ultimately landfilled, incinerated, or contaminated along the way. The reality, however, was more nuanced. Many systems functioned as intended, but limited infrastructure and the challenges of developing new waste streams meant that not all sorted materials successfully reached recycling facilities. While these cases were largely isolated and reflected the growing pains of an emerging system, the waste management sector has since improved its practices and become more transparent. Nonetheless, those early stage events quickly became a convenient argument for those looking for a reason not to recycle at all.
The New Excuse: “Recycling Costs Too Much”
Today, a different argument tends to surface. Recycling is often described as inefficient, costly, or economically questionable. And there is a core of truth in this. Glass recycling thrives, with rates exceeding 75%, and often proves cost-effective because of the energy savings it generates. Plastic recycling, by contrast, struggles with effective recycling rates of around 10%. It frequently costs 1.5 to 3 times more than producing virgin material!
This clear difference in economics helps explain why glass recycling can largely sustain itself. Plastic recycling faces a much tougher economic reality and it often depends on subsidies or legal requirements to remain competitive. So yes, for plastic for instance, it is not (yet) economic advantageous to recycle. But this way of framing the issue misses the point entirely. Recycling is not a cost-saving exercise, and reducing it to that metric distorts its purpose. Its real function is to keep valuable materials in circulation for as long as possible, reducing the constant demand for new extraction in a world where resources are finite.
A World of Limited Resources
Every aluminium can, plastic package, glass bottle, or cardboard box represents resources extracted from nature, whether through mining, logging, or the use of energy, water, and transport required to turn raw materials into something we can use for a few moments before discarding them.
- Aluminum: Making a new can from scratch uses 95% more energy than recycling one; recycling aluminum saves enough electricity to run a TV for 3 hours per can (1).
- Plastic: Producing 1 kg of new plastic requires about 2 liters of water and emits 3 kg of CO₂, while recycling it cuts those emissions by roughly 70% (2).
- Glass: Melting recycled glass (cullet) uses 30% less energy than melting raw sand, and every ton of recycled glass saves 1.2 tons of raw materials from being mined (3).
- Cardboard: Making new paperboard consumes 40 liters of water per kilogram, but recycling it slashes water use by 50% and energy use by 60% (4).
The bottom line, every time we separate for recycling, we aren’t just saving a bin space; we are preventing the extraction of raw earth, the burning of fossil fuels, and the draining of freshwater reserves needed to make that item from scratch.
Confronting Overconsumption
Recycling alone cannot fix the root cause of our environmental crisis: overconsumption. No amount of sorting can keep pace with the huge volume of goods we produce and discard. However, in a finite world where resources are not infinite, recycling serves as a crucial brake on the continual extraction of new materials, turning waste back into a resource.
We often ask whether recycling is financially worthwhile. That is the wrong question. We should, instead, be asking if wasting resources is acceptable.
Not everything that matters can be measured in immediate economic terms. Biodiversity, clean water, fertile soils, and natural resources all carry value far beyond any market price. Keeping this planet within the environmental conditions that support our species, has no price.
The Message of our Reflection
Ultimately, sustainable behavior is not a matter of convenience, but of consistency. Holidays may pause our work, but not our responsibility, and recycling is less about saving a few cents than about recognising and respecting the value of the resources that made what we consume possible in the first place.
(1) Aluminum Association. (2022). The environmental footprint of semi-fabricated aluminum products. https://www.aluminum.org
(2) European Environment Agency. (2023). Plastic packaging: From waste to resource. EEA Report No 12/2023. https://www.eea.europa.eu
(3) Glass Packaging Institute. (2024). Glass packaging: The sustainable choice. https://glasspackaging.com
(4) United States Environmental Protection Agency. (2023). Advancing sustainable materials management: 2023 facts and figures. https://www.epa.gov/facts-and-figures-about-materials-waste-and-recycling

